On The Bay Boutique, Bar & Cafe Menu (Update 2025)

On The Bay Boutique, Bar & Cafe at 51034 Washington St in New Baltimore, MI offers a unique dining experience with a diverse menu of cocktail bar, sandwich, and seafood options. The restaurant provides various amenities such as outdoor seating, live music, and a full bar, making it a perfect spot for a date night or casual hangout. The cozy and welcoming atmosphere, along with the friendly staff, create a comfortable dining environment. Customers rave about the delicious Spanish coffee, lobster bisque, lobster roll, and lobster mac and cheese. The attention to detail in serving generous portions of lobster in dishes has impressed many patrons. With rave reviews for the food, ambiance, and service, On The Bay Boutique, Bar & Cafe is a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts and those seeking a memorable dining experience with a touch of elegance and warmth.

APPETIZERS On The Bay

Steak Bites

Filet Mignon Steak Tips with a side of creamy horseradish and zip sauce

$16.00

Sweet And Spicy Tempura Shrimp

Crispy shrimp tossed in a sweet chili sauce served over a bed of greens and finished with pineapple tid bits.

$14.00

Steamed Mussels

pound steamed then tossed in a light sauce of butter, garlic cloves, and lime juice, served with toasted ciabatta bread.

$15.00

Sweet Sriracha Lobster And Shrimp Dip

Topped with scallions and Bay seasoning, served with toasted Ciabatta bread.

$16.00

Loaded Red Skins

Red Skin potatoes coated with garlic parm, cheese blend topped with bacon, drizzled sour cream and scallions

$10.00

Jumbo Pretzel

oz with your choice of salted or everything bagel seasoning and served with queso dip.

$16.00

Spinach And Artichoke Dip

Topped with Parmesan and served with corn tortilla chips.

$11.00

Loaded Nachos

Corn Tortilla Chips, topped with chicken or pulled pork, jalapenos, tomatoes, red onions, and a blend of white and mild queso cheese sauces.

$16.00

Brussel Sprouts

Roasted then drizzled with a balsamic truffle glaze and Feta and real bacon

$12.00

Bosco Sticks

() Mozzarella cheese stuffed breadsticks, sprinkled with garlic and a blend of cheeses, and served with ranch or marinara sauce.

$11.00

Chips And Dips

Corn tortilla chips, served with mild queso cheese sauce and salsa.

$8.00

Hawaiian Sliders

Key-lime BBQ pulled pork and grilled pineapples on three Hawaiian rolls served with chips and pineapple coleslaw

$8.00

Lobster Surf And Turf

Lobster, Shrimp, Filet Tips, Red Skins or Rice and side salad or coleslaw

$42.00

Lobster Roll

Lobster served hot on Hawaiian rolls with a sauce of house made seasoned butter, and your choice of pineapple coleslaw or pasta salad.

$24.00

Lobster Flatbread

Garlic Parmesan sauce, topped with lobster, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, then drizzled with our signature key lime, tangerine sweet sauce.

$24.00

Lobster Mac 'N Cheese

Cavatappi pasta tossed in a rich and creamy blend of white cheeses, then topped with lobster and Bay seasoning.

$24.00

Lobster Rice Bowl

Lobster, long grain white rice, celery, red cabbage, pineapples, carrots, seared with a honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, sprinkled of scallions.

$24.00

Lobster Tacos

Lobster served hot in flour tortillas with a sauce of house made seasoned butter, atop pineapple coleslaw, pineapple mango salsa, drizzled with honey pineapple teryaki glaze. Finished with scallions and fresh sliced lime wedges

$24.00

Lobster Bisque

Made fresh daily, finished with a sprinkle of lobster

$12.00

Lobster And Shrimp Dip

Lobster meat and Shrimp, topped with scallions and bay seasoning, served with toasted ciabatta bread.

$16.00

Lobster Omelette / Sat & Sun Only

Four Egg, Lobster meat and Cheese served with red skin potatoes

$19.99

LOBSTER DISHES

LAND, SEA & PASTA DINNERS

Filet Mignon Tips Dinner

Served with Red Skins or Rice, and Dinner Salad or Pineapple slaw and Dinner Roll

$29.00

Brisket Burnt Ends Dinner

Savory, smokehouse burnt ends, served with roasted Brussels sprouts topped with Feta and balsamic truffle glaze, roasted redskin potatoes or sweet chili rice, and pineapple coleslaw or pasta salad.

$24.00

Seafood Pasta

Lobster Meat, Mussels and Shrimp tossed in Angel Hair Pasta seafood Cream Sauce

$34.00

Grilled Salmon

Grilled to perfection, served with roasted Brussels sprouts topped with Feta and balsamic truffle glaze, roasted redskin potatoes or sweet chili rice, and pineapple coleslaw or pasta salad.

$24.00

Blackened Mahi Mahi

Lightly coated with blackening seasoning and grilled to perfection, served with roasted Brussels sprouts topped with Feta and balsamic truffle glaze, roasted redskin potatoes or sweet chili rice, and pineapple coleslaw or pasta salad.

$24.00

Bay Pasta

Our signature key lime piccata sauce, artichoke, and capers tossed in an angel hair pasta and choice of mahi, chicken, salmon

$26.00

Mac 'N Cheese Dinner

Cavatappi pasta tossed in a rich and creamy blend of white cheeses.

$8.00

Chicken Strip Dinner

Crispy all-white chicken served with our signature Key Lime BBQ sauce. Served with chips and a choice of pineapple coleslaw or pasta salad.

$14.99

Lobster Rice Bowl

Lobster, long grain white rice, celery, red cabbage, pineapples, carrots, seared with a honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, sprinkled with scallions.

$24.00

Shrimp Rice Bowl

Grilled or blackened shrimp, long grain white rice, celery, red cabbage, pineapples, and carrots, seared with a honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, sprinkled with scallions.

$19.00

Burnt Ends Rice Bowl

Savory smokehouse burnt ends, long grain white rice, celery, red cabbage, pineapples, carrots, seared with a honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, sprinkled of scallions.

$19.00

Chicken Rice Bowl

Grilled chicken, long grain white rice, celery, red cabbage, pineapples, carrots, seared with a honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, sprinkled of scallions.

$19.00

Tropical Rice Bowl

Long grain white rice, celery, red cabbage, pineapples, carrots, seared with a honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, sprinkled of scallions.

$12.00

Andouille Sausage Rice Bowl

Andouille Sausage over white rice with Celery, Carrots and cabbage bits in a Teriyaki Sauce. ask your server about GF

$19.00

RICE BOWLS

BURGERS SANDWICHES TACOS

Bacon Jam Burger

Two /lb. Angus beef patties and Swiss cheese topped with bacon and bacon-habanero jam, served with lettuce and tomato on a Brioche bun. Served with chips.

$12.00

Bay Burger

Two /lb. Angus beef patties, American cheese and our signature Key Lime BBQ sauce served with lettuce and tomato on a Brioche bun. Served with chips

$12.00

Lobster Tacos

Lobster served hot in flour tortillas with a sauce of house made seasoned butter, atop pineapple coleslaw, pineapple mango salsa, drizzled with honey pineapple teryaki glaze. Finished with scallions and fresh sliced lime wedges

$24.00

Burnt Ends Or Chicken Tacos

Slow smoked burnt ends or pulled pork topped with pineapple coleslaw, pineapple mango salsa, queso fresco, drizzled with honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, then finished with scallions and fresh sliced lime wedges.

$19.00

Mahi Mahi Or Shrimp Tacos

Mahi Mahi or Shrimp lightly coated with blackening seasoning, grilled to perfection, topped with remoulade, Asian slaw, pineapple mango salsa, then finished with scallions and fresh sliced lime wedges.

$19.00

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Grilled Chicken Breast, bacon and swiss cheese with Peach Jam on a brioche bun served with chips

$12.00

Cuban Sandwich

Slow smoked pulled pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and yellow mustard served on a grilled Ciabatta roll. Served with chips.

$14.00

Chicken Salad Croissant

Chicken Salad with cranberries, celery & Granny Smith Apple chunks on a buttery croissant. Served with chips

$11.00

Lobster Flatbread

Garlic parmesan sauce, topped with lobster, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, then drizzled with our signature key lime, tangerine sweet sauce.

$24.00

Dill Pickle Flatbread Pizza

Ranch, topped with grilled chicken, bacon, dill pickle, then drizzled with ranch.

$16.00

Hawaiian Chicken Flatbread Pizza

Key lime BBQ sauce, topped with grilled chicken, bacon, mozzarella, pineapple, then drizzled with our signature key lime BBQ and our signature key lime, tangerine sweet sauce.

$16.00

Pepperoni And Bacon Lover's Flatbread

Key lime BBQ sauce, topped with mozzarella, pepperoni, bacon, queso fresco, then drizzled with our signature key lime tangerine sweet sauce.

$16.00

Margherita Flatbread

Marinara sauce, topped with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, fresh basil, then drizzled with basil pesto olive oil.

$16.00

FLATBREAD PIZZA

SOUPS SALADS SIDES

Jumbo Pretzel

oz with your choice of salted or everything bagel seasoning and served with queso dip.

$16.00

Layer Cobb Salad Add Protein

Mixed greens, hard boiled egg, bacon, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, feta, kalamata olives, topped with pineapple mango salsa, served with southwest ranch.

$12.00

Spinach And Artichoke Dip

Topped with Parmesan and served with corn tortilla chips.

$11.00

Soup Of The Day

See website for Daily Soups: Chicken Tortilla, Clam Chowder, Chicken 'n Dumplings, Split Pea, Chicken Noodle, Loaded Baked Potato, Minestrone, Gumbo, Lasagna with Turkey Sausage. ADD A BREAD BOWL $

$6.00

Roasted Brussels Sprouts

Topped with Feta, then drizzled with balsamic truffle glaze and real bacon bits

$11.00

Side Mac 'N Cheese

Cavatappi pasta tossed in a rich and creamy blend of white cheeses.

$8.00

Pineapple Coleslaw

Homemade creamy coleslaw with bits of pineapple.

$4.00

Roasted Garlic Redskin Potatoes

$8.00

Dinner Salad

loaded dinner salad

Tiramisu

An elegant and rich layered Italian dessert made with delicate ladyfinger cookies, espresso, and mascarpone Italian custard.

$8.00

Key Lime Pie

Tart & Sweet - A delicious graham cracker crust filled to the brim with a creamy lime filling.

$8.00

Peanut Butter Explosion Mini Cake

Layered chocolate genoise, rich & velvety peanut butter mousse, topped with brownie bits, peanut butter chips, drizzled in fudge.

$8.00

Boozy Smoothies, Scoops, Floats And Slushies

Alcohol infused ice cream and smoothies.

Boozy Floats

Premium Vanilla bean Ice Cream Drinks and Floats

DESSERT MENU

FULL COCKTAIL BAR

BOOZY SMOOTHIES, RUM RUNNERS, FROZEN CONCOCTIONS AND MARGARITAS

We offer a variety of fun Tiki cocktail and specialty drinks, Boozy Smoothies and ice cream drinks with alcohol.

ESPRESSO BAR & COFFEE SHOP

A variety of premium coffee liqueurs, cocktails and non- alcoholic coffee drinks.

TROPICAL COCKTAIL BAR

Bartender having fun with tropical cocktails.

ALCOHOL, BEER AND WINE

On The Bay offers a Full Bar with a variety of rare rums, bourbons, tequila, mixed drinks, beer and wine.

Tiki Cocktails, Tiki Mugs And Souvenir Glasses

We sell TIKI EVERYTHING!

COFFEE COCKTAILS TO GO

We offer fun espresso and coffee cocktails and mocktails

OUTDOOR IGLOO DINING

Metro Detroit's Finest outdoor dining under heated gazebos with fire tables and patio heaters for a year round outdoor dining experience for - guests. Call ahead ..

Holiday Espresso And Hot Cocoa Bar

We offer a full range of extraordinary Espresso and Coffees. From rich and strong to sweet and velvety.

SMOOTHIES

Over real whole fruit smoothie combinations. Acai, Dragon fruit, Passion Fruit

$10.00

Speciality Coffee Or Tea

Latte, Frappes, Cappuccino, and more...

Hot Cocoa Bar

Hot cocoa served daily.. with whip cream and cocoa sprinkles

Premium Shakes And Malts

Creamy healthy real fruit shakes and malts made with premium ice cream.

$8.00

SLUSHIES With Or Without Alcohol

Watermelon, Blue Raspberry, Lemonade, Wine Slushies, Pina Colada, Apple Cider and more

Infused Ice Tea

One of our favorite ways to enjoy tea! We offer a variety of fresh fruit infused cold brew summer teas.

$4.00

JUICE POP Coffee Tea

Fresh Juices, Ice Coffee, Tea, Hot Cocoa, Coke, and Pepsi products

$3.00

PREMIUM TROPICAL SMOOTHIES HEALTHY SHAKES COFFEE TEA

Signature Tropical Cocktails

Rum Runner

White rum, dark rum, blackberry brandy, banana liquor, orange and pineapple juices, served on the rocks.

$10.00

Miami Vice

Equal parts frozen strawberry daiquiri and frozen pina colada.

$10.00

Rum-Rita

Equal parts Rum Runner and frozen margarita.

$10.00

Boozy Smoothies

Add your choice of alcohol to any of our smoothies.

$14.00

Boozy Slushies

Add your choice of alcohol to any of our slushies.

Mai Tai

Rum, orange curacao, fresh lime juice and orgeat syrup.

$10.00

Pain Killer

Rum, pineapple juice, cream of coconut, orange juice. Sprinkled with nutmeg.

$10.00

Hurricane

Rum, lime juice, orange juice, passion fruit puree, grenadine and simple syrup.

$10.00

Strawberry Daiquiri

White rum, lime juice, simple syrup, strawberries.

$10.00

Pina Colada

White rum, coconut cream, pineapple juice.

$10.00

Bloody Mary $ Loaded $.

Vodka, mild bloody mary mix. Served with a rimmed cup of house made seasoning. Loaded: skewered sausage and cheese, shrimp, olive, pickle, celery stick, lime and lemon.

$9.00

Long Island Bay

Vodka, gin, tequila, rum, triple sec, sweet and sour mix, splash of Coke.

$9.00

Moscow Mule

Vodka, ginger beer, fresh lime juice, on the rocks then finished with a lime garnish.

$9.00

Cranberry Mule

Fresh muddled cranberries, vodka, ginger beer, fresh lime and cranberry juices, on the rocks.

$9.00

Blushing Lemonade

Citrus vodka, blended on the rocks with strawberry lemonade.

$8.00

Mojito

Fresh muddled mint, rum, fresh lime juice, on the rocks with club soda.

$8.00

Mimosa

Salmon Creek Brut, blended with orange juice.

$7.00

Cosmopolitan

Citrus vodka, triple sec, fresh lime juice, then finished with a splash of cranberry juice.

$8.00

Classic Cocktails

Beer

Beer

Landshark $ | Coors Light $ | Miller Lite $ Bud Light $ | Michelob Ultra $ | Blue Moon $

$4.00

Riff Pinot Grigio

Medium-bodied with a fresh mouth-watering finish, dry and crisp.

$7.00

Gen Chardonnay

Full-bodied, buttery with toasty overtones and plenty of juicy ripe pear and apple flavors.

$7.00

Morgan Chardonnay

Aromas of Asian pear, graham cracker, and baking spices. On the palate, a light touch of toffee and Nilla wafer.

$10.00

Loosen Bros. Riesling

Aromas and flavors of delicate flowers, ripe apple, green apple and a hint of mineral notes.

$7.00

Sunday Funday Sauvignon Blanc

Crisp and refreshing entry of pineapple and fresh cut grass leads to a vibrant finish of citrusy goodness.

$7.00

Salmon Creek Brut (Sparkling)

Aromas of pear and green apple with a thin body and a quick apricot, morello cherry, and lychee finish.

$11.00

White Wine

Red Wine

Hayes Cabernet Sauvignon

Red cherry, anise, hint of vanilla. Well balanced, medium tannins, spicy, coffee finish.

$8.00

Borealis Pinot Noir

Cranberry, cherry, cinnamon, followed by flavors of cherries, dried figs and cocoa, finish of cinnamon and white pepper.

$11.00

Mount Diablo Highlands Red Blend

Plum and red cherries. Notes of toffee, coffee bean and white pepper. Balance between fruitiness and a touch of spice and oak.

$8.00

Carbliss

Please ask your server for available flavors.

$6.50

Seltzers